Category: Labor Protection Supplies

How to Inspect Safety Shoes: Impact and Puncture

Safety shoes are a high-volume PPE item on construction sites and in factories — and one of the most problem-prone. Impact and puncture protection are their two core functions, and accepting deliveries by appearance and count alone easily lets substandard shoes into the warehouse. This guide explains, under the current national standard, what really needs checking on delivery.

Know the Standard First: GB 21148-2020 Is the Current Edition

The current national standard for safety shoes in China is GB 21148-2020, Foot Protection — Safety Footwear, effective 1 August 2021, replacing the 2007 edition. Write the full standard number, including the year, on purchase contracts and acceptance forms.

Impact protection is graded by toe protection: Class AN1 requires the toe cap to withstand 200 J of impact energy and 15 kN of compression; Class AN2 requires 300 J of impact energy and 20 kN of compression. High-impact scenarios such as construction, metallurgy and heavy machinery generally need AN2; AN1 is enough for medium-risk settings such as warehousing and ordinary workshops. On delivery, check the class agreed in the contract first, then check that the markings and the report match it.

Puncture protection requires a penetration force of at least 1100 N. Metal inserts are tested directly on penetration force; for non-metallic inserts, the nail tip must not protrude within 10 seconds under 1100 N. The insert sits inside the sole and should not move without the shoe being damaged. Without a test report showing 1100 N, puncture protection has effectively not been checked at all.

Two more indicators are often overlooked: energy absorption in the seat region must be at least 20 J, and slip resistance is graded to SRA requirements. Slip resistance comes in three grades — SRA, SRB and SRC — and SRC, which meets both SRA and SRB, has the highest slip-resistance requirement.

What to Check on Delivery: Markings, Report, Appearance

Step one, check the markings. Shoes should carry clear, durable markings covering at least the standard number, manufacturer, model, size and protection symbols. Be cautious of blurred or incomplete markings, or of a single easily peeled-off sticker. The protection symbols must match the contract: shoes bought for puncture protection should show the puncture symbol; shoes bought for anti-static use should show the anti-static symbol.

Step two, check the test report. The model, manufacturer and standard number on the report must match the delivered goods, the report must be within its validity period, and the measured values for key items must be listed — not just the word "pass". The figures for impact, puncture and slip resistance should all be findable in the report. If the report doesn't match the goods, or only an expired report is available, ask the supplier to provide a new one.

Step three, check appearance and workmanship: the toe cap should show no obvious deformation, the sole should not be unglued or cracked, the upper should not be damaged, and the left and right shoes should match in size and style. Spot checks should cover different sizes. If batch workmanship problems appear, seal the whole batch first — don't issue shoes while still checking them.

Simple On-Site Checks

Without test equipment, several simple checks can still be done on site: press the toe cap by hand — it should feel hard and resist denting, and the upper should show no obvious dent after you release it; bend the sole — the midsole should feel stiff from the insert, and the whole shoe should not feel soft and floppy; place the shoe on a flat surface — the sole should sit flat and not lift visibly; and weigh the shoes — the same model and size should weigh about the same, and any pair noticeably lighter than the rest should be checked separately.

Don't use destructive methods such as hitting the toe cap with a hammer or stabbing the sole with a nail. A destructively tested shoe can't be used, and one strike says nothing about the whole batch. Real impact and puncture performance is proven by the test report — on-site checks are only a supporting measure.

When to Ask for Replacement or Return

Buyers can ask for replacement or return when: markings are missing or don't match the contract; the test report doesn't match the goods; there are batch workmanship defects such as deformed toe caps or unglued or cracked soles; sizes don't match the order; or the production date is too old and poor storage has left the soles aged and sticky. Keep records of the acceptance process: take photos, note quantities, write an acceptance form and have both sides sign it — so there is evidence if problems arise.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are impact protection and puncture protection the same thing?

No. Impact protection is the toe cap stopping heavy objects from crushing toes; puncture protection is the midsole insert stopping nails and rebar ends from piercing the sole. Confirm both separately when buying — some shoes have only one of them.

Which is better, a steel toe cap or a composite toe cap?

Both can meet 200 J impact protection; they differ in weight, conductivity and corrosion resistance. Composite caps are lighter and non-conductive, suiting electrical work; steel caps are tough and durable. Choose by the work scenario, not by material price.

How long can safety shoes be worn before replacing them?

There is no single fixed schedule — it depends on use. Replace shoes at once if the toe cap is deformed after a heavy impact, the tread is worn flat, the midsole insert is exposed, or the upper is damaged. Set up a regular inspection system instead of waiting for shoes to break.

How many pairs should I spot-check on delivery?

Small batches can be fully checked visually; large batches should be spot-checked by proportion, covering every size. If a spot check finds problems, double the sample; if problems persist, reject the whole batch. Put the sampling rate and rejection rules in the purchase contract.

WhatsApp 18300232331 Get a Free Quote
Chat Get a Quote